Which is better for a busy family kitchen?

The Moen EXL100C. Its 1 HP motor and 32 oz chamber handle larger, tougher loads per run. The Badger 5XP is fine for light to moderate use.

Both are built for years of residential use. The Badger's induction motor has a long track record and a much larger base of 8,698 ratings; the Moen's stainless steel grinding parts resist corrosion. Neither carries a published lifespan figure here.

Is the Moen worth the extra money?

Only if you grind bones, fibrous scraps or large batches often. At $254.70 versus $159 at Distritech as of November 3, the Badger is the better value for typical use.

Do I need to buy a power cord for the Badger?

Yes. The Badger 5XP ships without a cord, so add one or hardwire it. The Moen comes with a pre-installed cord.

Will either fit my existing sink flange?

The Badger uses Lift and Latch for a standard 3-bolt sink connection. The Moen fits most 3-bolt assemblies and allows a maximum sink thickness of 1/2 in. Check your sink thickness before buying the Moen.

Are they septic-safe?

Both are listed as compatible with properly maintained septic systems. Keep food waste volume reasonable either way.

InSinkErator Garbage Disposal, Badger 5XP, 3/4 HP Continuous Feed vs Moen exl100c EX Series 1 HP Continuous Garbage Disposal

The Badger 5XP is the safer buy for most kitchens: a 3/4 HP induction motor, a 4.6 rating from over 8,600 shoppers, and a lower price. The Moen EXL100C gives you 1 HP, a 32 oz grind chamber and a pre-installed power cord, but it costs $254.70 and has a thinner 4.3 rating from 225 shoppers. Buy the Badger if budget and proven reliability matter most. Buy the Moen if you grind heavy scraps often and want the extra power and cord included.

Ask our shopping agent