Isabella 14" Hybrid Pillow Top Mattress vs Sweetnight Coolnest 16 Inch Queen Size Hybrid Mattress

The Sweetnight Coolnest is the better mattress for most shoppers. It adds cooling gel memory foam, pocket coils and a 16-inch profile, and 546 ratings average 4.5 out of 5. The Isabella is a basic 14-inch innerspring pillow top that works with adjustable bases and comes in five sizes, including Twin XL. It suits a guest room or a tight budget, but owners of similar basic innersprings report a bouncier feel and more motion transfer.

• Choose the Isabella if you need an adjustable-base-compatible mattress in Twin XL or King and want a simple, bouncy innerspring feel.
• Choose the Sweetnight Coolnest if you want cooling gel foam, pocket coils, a taller profile and stronger owner ratings in a Queen.