ITP Mud Lite AT Tire vs GBC Dirt Devil ATV/UTV Tire

Both are 25x12-9 bias-ply ATV tires with 4.8-star ratings, but they suit different riders. The ITP Mud Lite AT is the better pick for mud and mixed trail riding, with a lighter carcass and a long track record as one of the most popular mud-trail tires. The GBC Dirt Devil is a 6-ply, 20/32-inch deep V-tread tire with a 4-year limited warranty, better for hard pack, gravel and light mud where cut resistance matters more than flotation. Owners of both report solid wear; the Mud Lite has far more ratings behind it, so its reputation is better tested.

• Choose the ITP Mud Lite AT if you ride muddy trails and want a lighter, versatile all-conditions tire with a long, well-reviewed track record.
• Choose the GBC Dirt Devil if you want a 6-ply, puncture-resistant tire with a 4-year limited warranty for hard pack, gravel and light mud.