Jack Post Large Plastic Christmas Tree Stand vs Yard Butler ButlerSanta's Helper Large White Tree Stand
Both are steel-and-plastic stands for large live trees, and the choice comes down to trunk size and how much water you want to carry. The Jack-Post takes trunks up to about 5.5 inches and holds more water, with a 5-year warranty and a 4.7 rating from 16 owners. The Yard Butler fits taller trees up to 11 feet, uses four T-bolts for faster straightening, and its welded round base is the sturdier build. Buy the Jack-Post for a thick-trunked tree; buy the Yard Butler for a tall tree and easier setup.
- Choose the Jack-Post if your tree has a thick trunk near 5 inches and you want the larger reservoir and a 5-year warranty.
- Choose the Yard Butler if your tree runs 10 to 11 feet, has a slimmer trunk, and you want welded steel and quick T-bolt tightening.
Prices
- Jack Post Large Plastic Christmas Tree Stand: $22.05 at eBay (checked today)
- Yard Butler ButlerSanta's Helper Large White Tree Stand: $60.79 at Walmart (checked today)
- Difference: the Jack Post Large Plastic Christmas Tree Stand is $38.74 cheaper than the Yard Butler ButlerSanta's Helper Large White Tree Stand today

