JBL Endurance Peak 3 vs Powerbeats Pro 2

The Powerbeats Pro 2 is the stronger pick for most athletes: it adds active noise cancellation, heart rate monitoring, IPX4 sweat resistance and a nickel-titanium ear hook that holds its shape. The Endurance Peak 3 counters with a higher IP68 rating on paper, a hook design that owners say stays put, and long battery life, but reviewers report muddy sound, tight fits and touch controls that fail. Buy the JBL if you want a simple, rugged-feeling sport bud and value the sealed shell; buy the Beats if you want features and a more polished fit.

• Choose the JBL Endurance Peak 3 if you want a secure ear-hook sport bud with a high dust and water rating and you can live with mixed reports on sound and touch controls.
• Choose the Apple Powerbeats Pro 2 if you want active noise cancellation, heart rate monitoring and a proven ear-hook fit for training.