Which is better for a traditional Christmas pop sound?

Jingle All the Way. It is a various-artists collection of Christmas, traditional pop and easy listening. Johnny Cash Christmas Spirit is country.

Which one is less likely to skip?

Johnny Cash Christmas Spirit. Buyers of Jingle All the Way report pressings that skip on the first song of side A and defective copies. No such complaints are reported for the Cash LP.

Is the Jingle All the Way LP new?

The $25.00 copy at eBay is used, graded VG+ for record and sleeve. Two stores price it new, so check which listing you are buying.

Is Johnny Cash Christmas Spirit worth the extra?

It isn't extra. At $23.99 at Amazon as of November 7, 2026 it is $1.01 cheaper than the $25.00 Jingle All the Way at eBay.

Which has the better vinyl for collectors?

Jingle All the Way, if you want colored vinyl. It is a Walmart-exclusive red and green pressing. The Cash LP is standard black.

Can I return a defective copy of either?

Opened media returns are the risk with Jingle All the Way; buyers report difficulty returning defective copies. Check the store's policy before you open either record.

Jingle All the Way Christmas Vinyl LP vs Johnny Cash Christmas Spirit

Buy the Johnny Cash Christmas Spirit LP if you want one artist's take on Christmas and a lower price: $23.99 at Amazon as of November 7, 2026, versus $25.00 at eBay for Jingle All the Way. Buy Jingle All the Way if you want a various-artists mix on red and green vinyl and accept the risk of a pressing that skips. The two are close in price, so the choice comes down to whether you want a single voice or a compilation.

Today the Johnny Cash Christmas Spirit costs $1.01 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.