Jo Malone Men's Cologne Discovery Set vs Caswell Massey Heritage Cologne Discovery Set
The Jo Malone set is the better choice for anyone who wants to explore a modern, layerable fragrance wardrobe: six 1.5 mL vials covering woody, smoky and ambery scents, rated 4.8 out of 5 from 216 reviews. The Caswell Massey set is smaller at three colognes, but it is made in the USA and skips parabens, sulfates and phthalates, and its classic barbershop-style scents suit traditional tastes. Jo Malone wins on variety and scent range; Caswell Massey wins on a cleaner formula and a more old-school character.
- Choose the Jo Malone set if you want the widest range of scents to try and layer, and you like woody, smoky and ambery profiles.
- Choose the Caswell Massey set if you prefer a few classic American colognes and want a formula free of parabens, sulfates and phthalates.
Prices
- Jo Malone Men's Cologne Discovery Set: $28.00 at Kohl's (checked today)
- Caswell Massey Heritage Cologne Discovery Set: $56.25 at Ulta Beauty (checked today)
- Difference: the Jo Malone Men's Cologne Discovery Set is $28.25 cheaper than the Caswell Massey Heritage Cologne Discovery Set today

