John Deere S130 Lawn Tractor vs Troy-Bilt Pony 42 Riding Mower
The John Deere S130 is the better tractor for most buyers. Its 22 hp V-twin runs smoother and holds torque in tall, thick grass, and the hydrostatic transmission gives infinite speed control with no shifting. The Troy-Bilt Pony 42 is a simpler, lighter-duty machine with a 15.5 hp single and a 7-speed manual, and its 3.5-of-5 owner rating reflects more complaints about cut quality and reliability. Buy the Deere for a lawn you mow often and want to keep for years; buy the Pony only if a basic rider is all you need.
- Choose the John Deere S130 if you want a smooth V-twin, foot-controlled hydrostatic drive and a deck that adjusts in fine 1/4-inch steps.
- Choose the Troy-Bilt Pony 42 if you want a straightforward, low-effort rider with a step-through frame and dash-mounted speed changes.
Prices
- John Deere S130 Lawn Tractor: $530.00 at Colabmod (last seen Nov 15)
- Troy-Bilt Pony 42 Riding Mower: $90.46 at Quality Furniture (last seen Nov 9)
- Difference: the Troy-Bilt Pony 42 Riding Mower is $439.54 cheaper than the John Deere S130 Lawn Tractor at the latest prices (Nov 9 and Nov 15)

