Johnny Was Dreamer Floral Maxi Dress vs Johnny Was Womens The Janie Favorite Short Hankerchief Hem Dress
Buy the Dreamer Floral Maxi if you want a full-length statement dress for a vacation or garden party. Buy The Janie if you want an easy, machine-washable everyday dress with a relaxed fit. The Janie has recent pricing history around $54 to $56, while the Dreamer's listing carries no price data here, so compare live store prices before deciding.
Ask our shopping agent
Johnny Was Dreamer Floral Maxi Dress
Choose the Dreamer Floral Maxi if you want a floor-length floral dress with UPF 50+ sun protection and chlorine-resistant stretch fabric for resort or poolside wear.
Pros
- UPF 50+ sun protection for outdoor events
- Chlorine and fade resistant stretch fabric
- Full-length floral print makes a statement
- Works for vacations, garden parties and formal occasions
Cons
- Only XS listed
- No care instructions given
- No price data to compare against The Janie
- Polyamide blend, not the cotton and silk the description claims
What separates them
| Johnny Was Dreamer Floral Maxi Dress | Johnny Was Womens The Janie Favorite Short Hankerchief Hem Dress | |
|---|---|---|
| Length | Maxi, floor-length silhouette | About 25.5 inches from shoulder to hem, above the knee |
| Fabric | 83% polyamide / 17% elastane (Xtra Life Lycra) | 95% rayon / 5% spandex |
| Sun protection | UPF 50+ | Not rated |
| Chlorine resistance | Chlorine, fade and pill resistant | Not rated for chlorine |
| Care | Not stated on the listing | Machine wash |
| Neckline and sleeves | Not specified | V-neck with short sleeves |
| Size range | Women's XS only as listed | Regular, petite and plus |
| Price |
Price history
$179.00$54.00
- Johnny Was Dreamer Floral Maxi Dress: lowest $179.00 on Nov 2 at Poshmark.
- Johnny Was Womens The Janie Favorite Short Hankerchief Hem Dress: lowest $54.00 on Nov 3 at 6pm.com.
Prices at every store
Johnny Was Dreamer Floral Maxi Dress
- MKE Closet RevivalCheck price at MKE Closet Revival
- PoshmarkCheck price at Poshmark
Johnny Was Womens The Janie Favorite Short Hankerchief Hem Dress
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- eBayCheck price at eBay
- PoshmarkCheck price at Poshmark
Specs compared
| Spec | Johnny Was Dreamer Floral Maxi Dress | Johnny Was Womens The Janie Favorite Short Hankerchief Hem Dress |
|---|---|---|
| Material | 83% Polyamide/17% Elastane | 95% Rayon 5% Spandex |
| Fabric | Xtra Life Lycra | — |
| Sun protection | UPF 50+ | — |
| Chlorine resistance | Chlorine, fade and pill resistant | — |
| Model height | 5'10" | — |
| Medium length | — | 26" |
| Medium bust | — | 39" |
| Shell | — | 95% rayon, 5% spandex |
| Length | — | About 25.5" from shoulder to hem |
| Department | — | Women's |
What reviewers say
Johnny Was Womens The Janie Favorite Short Hankerchief Hem Dress
Reviewers describe the dress as pretty, flattering and unique, with soft, breathable, well-made fabric. One notes it may run a little big because of the stretch.
Pros
- Pretty and flattering look
- Unique design
- Soft, breathable material
- Well-made
Cons
- May run a little big due to stretch
Questions and answers
- Which is better for a beach vacation?
- The Dreamer, if you want a long dress with UPF 50+ and chlorine resistance. The Janie is shorter and not rated for sun or chlorine.
- Which one is easier to care for?
- The Janie. It is machine washable. The Dreamer's listing gives no care instructions, so check the label before washing.
- Does The Janie fit true to size?
- Reviewers say it may run a little big because of the stretch. Consider sizing down if you are between sizes.
- Is The Janie worth the price?
- At about $54 to $56 it is a low-cost casual dress that reviewers call well made and breathable. Whether it beats the Dreamer depends on whether you need a long dress.
- Which has more size options?
- The Janie, which comes in regular, petite and plus. The Dreamer is listed in XS only.
- Which fabric is better for hot weather?
- The Janie's rayon-spandex blend is described by reviewers as breathable. The Dreamer's polyamide-elastane is stretchy and swimwear-like, which suits pool and resort use.
More comparisons
- Johnny Was Vittoria Scarf Margot Blouse vs Johnny Was Womens The Janie Favorite Short Hankerchief Hem Dress
- Johnny Was White Button Up Blouse Shirt Top Embroidered Bohemian vs Johnny Was Dreamer Floral Maxi Dress
- Johnny Was White Button Up Blouse Shirt Top Embroidered Bohemian vs Johnny Was Womens The Janie Favorite Short Hankerchief Hem Dress