Jonathan Y Monkey Fist Rope Table Lamp vs Matthews Table Lamp
The Jonathan Y Monkey is the sturdier, brighter, more practical lamp: a 24-inch rope-knot base, a wide cotton drum shade, a 100-watt socket and a 9-watt LED bulb in the box. The Matthews is a slimmer 21-inch brass metal lamp with a ruffled white linen shade, capped at a 40-watt E12 candelabra bulb and no dimmer. Buy the Jonathan Y for a bedside or living room where you want real light and a nautical look; buy the Matthews for a small side table where a narrow, transitional accent matters more than brightness. Owners of rope-base lamps like the Jonathan Y praise the texture but note the base is bulky and heavy; the Matthews is light at 3 lb and easy to move, though its small shade and low wattage limit it to mood lighting.
- Choose the Jonathan Y Monkey if you want a bright, wide-shaded lamp with a textured nautical base and a bulb included.
- Choose the Matthews if you need a slim, light brass accent lamp for a small table and only soft light.
Prices
- Jonathan Y Monkey Fist Rope Table Lamp: $76.50 at Amazon (checked today)
- Matthews Table Lamp: $103.60 at Lulu and Georgia (checked today)
- Difference: the Jonathan Y Monkey Fist Rope Table Lamp is $27.10 cheaper than the Matthews Table Lamp today

