Jordan 1 High Emerald Green vs Athletic Works Women's Walking Shoes Jogger 2.0

These are not really rivals: one is a women's suede-and-leather high-top with Zoom Air, the other a knit walking shoe with an EVA midsole and Memory Foam insole. Buy the Jordan 1 High if you want a durable, collectible sneaker that holds up to daily wear and looks sharp with casual outfits. Buy the Athletic Works Jogger 2.0 if you want a light, breathable shoe for walking and errands. Owners of the Jordan 1 praise the materials and silhouette but note the stiff, heavy feel and break-in time; Athletic Works buyers rate it 4.4 out of 5 for comfort and value, though the knit upper and foam will wear faster.

• Choose the Jordan 1 High Emerald Green if you want a real leather and suede sneaker with Zoom Air that works as both footwear and a wardrobe piece.
• Choose the Athletic Works Jogger 2.0 if you need a light, breathable walking shoe for daily errands and don't care about sneaker culture.