Which is better for a petite shopper?

The Peggy straight-leg ankle jean. It is built for the petite frame and tapers to hit right at the ankle. The Secret Sauce 2.0 comes in petite/regular sizing but is a full wide leg.

Which is better for plus sizes?

The Secret Sauce 2.0. It comes in plus sizes 14W-24W, while the Peggy jean is petite only.

Which one is cheaper?

The Peggy straight leg at $69.00 at eBay as of November 7, 2026, versus $74.99 at Sunshine & Wine Boutique for the Secret Sauce 2.0 as of November 7, 2026.

Do both have tummy control?

Yes. Both are high-rise Judy Blue jeans with a tummy control feature. The Secret Sauce 2.0 describes a built-in control panel; the Peggy lists tummy control as a feature.

How should I size each pair?

Size down one from your true size in the Secret Sauce 2.0. The Peggy runs true to Judy Blue size, which is one down from your department size.

Which looks more dressed up?

The Peggy straight leg. Its non-distressed medium wash and clean ankle taper read more polished. The wide leg is the more casual, retro pick.

Judy Blue Secret Sauce 2.0 Wide Leg Jeans vs Judy Blue Petite Tummy Control Straight Jeans

Both are Judy Blue high-rise tummy-control jeans, so the real choice is silhouette and fit range. Pick the Secret Sauce 2.0 wide leg for a retro, elongating look in regular or plus sizes; pick the Peggy straight-leg ankle jean if you are petite and want a clean, tapered leg. On price, the straight leg is the cheaper buy at $69.00 at eBay as of November 7, 2026, against $74.99 at Sunshine & Wine Boutique for the wide leg as of November 7, 2026.

Today the Judy Blue Petite Tummy Control Straight Jeans costs $5.99 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.