Which is better for actual canning?

The Kerr set. It is a canning jar with two-piece Sure Tight lids and bands, and the maker rates the seal for up to 18 months. The 16-pack is sold mainly for storage and crafts.

Which holds more food?

The 16-pack. Its large jars hold 16 oz, twice the Kerr's 8 oz. The Kerr set gives you 12 jars of one size; the 16-pack gives you 8 large and 8 small.

Which is better for gifts and crafts?

The 16-pack. It includes labels and hemp rope and mixes sizes, which suits candles, favors and spice jars. The Kerr jars work for decor too but come plain.

Is the Kerr set worth the extra?

If you preserve food, yes. The price history shows $17.90 to $19.99 for 12 jars in early November 2026, and the seal rating and review record back it up. For storage only, the 16-pack may be enough.

Are both freezer safe?

Yes, both are listed as freezer safe. Leave headspace when freezing either one.

Which has better reviews?

Kerr: 4.7 out of 5 from 1,573 ratings. The 16-pack has 4.1 out of 5 from 11 ratings, which is too few to lean on.

Kerr Wide Mouth Mason Jars with Lids and Bands vs 16 Pack Mason Jars Set 8-16oz Wide Mouth + 8-4oz Regular Mouth Mason Jars with Seal Lids

Buy the Kerr set if you are actually canning or freezing: it is a proven half-pint canning jar with Sure Tight lids rated to hold a seal up to 18 months. Buy the 16-pack if you want a mixed set of large and small jars for storage, pickling, gifts or crafts. On price, the Kerr 12-pack ran $17.90 to $19.99 in early November 2026; the 16-pack has no price given here, so compare it at the stores before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent