- Which makes better lattes?
- Both use a built-in frother and K-Cup pods, so drinks are close. The Smart adds three frother speeds and a cold setting plus strength and temperature control, which gives you more room to tune the result.
- Which is better for small kitchens?
- Neither has a size edge: both measure 5.1 inches wide, 12.8 inches deep and 12.6 inches high, and both have a 42 oz reservoir. The Barista Bar's reservoir is removable for refilling at the sink.
- Do both take the same pods?
- Yes. Both brew any K-Cup pod, and both list a My K-Cup Universal Coffee Filter for ground coffee.
- Which has more brew size options?
- The Smart. It offers 2, 4, 6, 8, 10 and 12 oz, while the Barista Bar offers a 2 oz shot plus 8, 10 and 12 oz.
- Can I schedule coffee with either?
- Only the Smart. Its WiFi connection and Keurig app let you schedule a brew and start one remotely; the Barista Bar has no connectivity.
- Is the K-Café Smart worth stepping up to?
- Only if you will use WiFi brewing, BrewID and the app's Café Creations menu. If you just want coffee and froth, the Barista Bar does the core job.
- Which is better for iced coffee?
- Both handle it. The Smart has a Brew Over Ice setting that brews hot over ice; the Barista Bar has a Brew Over Ice button that starts hotter to extract flavor, then cools to limit ice melt.
- How does the Smart's brewing differ from the Barista Bar?
- The Smart uses Multistream technology, which Keurig says saturates the grounds more evenly than its K-Classic brewer. The Barista Bar lists standard single-serve brewing.
- Which frother handles dairy alternatives better?
- Both froth dairy alternatives such as oat, almond and soy. The Smart's own notes say nut milk froths like dairy but loses its bubbles quickly, and lactose-free milk is less reliable.
- Which machine is easier to refill and travel with?
- The Barista Bar lists a removable 42 oz reservoir that brews up to 4 cups between refills, and its maker is tumbler- and travel-mug-friendly. The Smart lists a 42 oz tank without saying it is removable.