Matoen Kids Foam Play Mat vs ProSource Kids Foam Puzzle Play Mat

Both are 3/8-inch interlocking EVA foam mats with a textured, wipe-clean surface, so the core product is nearly the same. The Matoen set rates higher with owners (4.9 from 165 ratings versus 4.4 from 80) and comes in multicolor, which suits a playroom. The ProSource set is the better pick for coverage: its 36-tile option reaches 6 x 6 ft with 24 border pieces and a zippered storage bag, while the Matoen tops out at 4 x 4 ft. Buy the ProSource if you need a large, finished-looking floor area; buy the Matoen if you want the smaller set with the stronger owner record.

• Choose the Matoen Kids Foam Play Mat if you want a compact 4 x 4-ft multicolor mat for tummy time and toddler play and you weigh owner ratings heavily.
• Choose the ProSource Kids Foam Puzzle Floor Play Mat if you need a bigger floor area, edge borders for a finished look, and a bag to store or carry the tiles.