L.L.Bean Wicked Good Venetian Slippers vs Dearfoams Sydney Shearling Scuff Slipper

The L.L.Bean Wicked Good Venetian is the warmer, more substantial slipper, with a real sheepskin lining and a suede upper that holds up over several winters. The Dearfoams Sydney is the lighter, water-resistant scuff that works indoors and out and comes in wide widths. Reviewers of the L.L.Bean praise the warmth and construction but report sizing runs small and the fleece packs down; Dearfoams owners rate it higher overall, though it is a thinner scuff. Buy the L.L.Bean for cold floors and a broken-in moccasin feel; buy the Dearfoams for a washable-feeling, water-resistant house shoe you can step outside in.

• Choose the L.L.Bean Wicked Good if you want a plush, genuine-shearling-lined Venetian for cold indoor wear and you are willing to size up.
• Choose the Dearfoams Sydney if you need a water-resistant scuff you can wear to the mailbox or patio and want a wide fit.