Larson Brisa Retractable Screen Door vs White Vinyl Hinged Screen Door 30x80 5-Bar
These are different jobs. The Brisa is a retractable screen that rolls away into a housing and fits a 36-in opening; the vinyl five-bar door is a fixed hinged door for a 30-in opening. Pick the Brisa if you want an unobstructed doorway most of the time and a screen only when you need it. Pick the vinyl door if you want a traditional porch look that stands up to pets and daily traffic. Owners of retractable screens praise the clear opening but report the spring and track need care; five-bar vinyl doors are simple and tough but always visible and block some light.
- Choose the Brisa if your doorway is 36 in wide and you want the screen to disappear into its housing when not in use.
- Choose the vinyl five-bar door if you have a 30-in opening and want a fixed, pet-resistant porch door with no moving parts.
Prices
- Larson Brisa Retractable Screen Door: $261.20 at Lowe's (checked today)
- White Vinyl Hinged Screen Door 30x80 5-Bar: $144.18 at The Home Depot (checked today)
- Difference: the White Vinyl Hinged Screen Door 30x80 5-Bar is $117.02 cheaper than the Larson Brisa Retractable Screen Door today

