Which is warmer for winter yard work?

The LeMieux Brooke 3-in-1. Its zip-out Sorona gilet adds insulation, while the Rainfoil Storm is an uninsulated shell that relies on layers underneath.

Which keeps rain out better?

The Rainfoil Storm has a stated 5K/5K rating, fully seam-sealed construction and a DWR Pro finish. The LeMieux is waterproof with waterproof zips but publishes no rating.

Is the LeMieux worth the extra money?

If you need one jacket for cold, wet riding and stable work, yes. At $210.75 versus $76.98 as of November 3, 2026, the Rainfoil is the better buy if you only want a rain shell.

Which is better for riding?

The LeMieux, which is cut true to size for equestrian use and resists hair and hay. The Rainfoil is a general outdoor shell with no riding vents.

Which packs smaller for travel?

The Rainfoil Storm at 518g. The LeMieux 3-in-1 is a bulkier jacket, especially with the gilet zipped in.

Does either have a detachable hood?

Only the LeMieux. Its hood detaches; the Rainfoil's hood is fixed.

LeMieux Women's Brooke 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket vs Women's Rainfoil Storm Waterproof Hooded Jacket

The LeMieux Brooke 3-in-1 is the warmer, more versatile pick for cold-weather riding and stable work, with a zip-out Sorona gilet and a shell that sheds hair and hay. The Eddie Bauer Rainfoil Storm is the better value rain shell at $76.98 at Eddie Bauer as of November 3, versus $210.75 at Old Mill Saddlery for the LeMieux. Buy the LeMieux if you need one jacket for winter yard work and hacking; buy the Rainfoil if you mainly want a packable, fully seam-sealed rain layer.

Today the Women's Rainfoil Storm Waterproof Hooded Jacket costs $133.77 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent