Lenovo ThinkStation P510 Workstation vs HP Elite SFF 600 G9 Desktop

Buy the Lenovo ThinkStation P510 if you need a real workstation: Xeon E5-1620, eight DDR4 slots, ECC memory support, four 3.5-inch bays, a 700W supply and room for a Quadro P5000 or P6000. Buy the HP Elite SFF 600 G9 if you want a compact, quiet, current office desktop with a fast six-core i5-12400, DDR5 and Windows 11 Pro. The P510 wins on expansion and certified graphics; the HP wins on single-thread speed, efficiency, size and modern platform support. Both are solid builds, but the P510 is a used mid-2010s platform and the HP is a current-generation machine.

• Choose the ThinkStation P510 if you run CAD, 3D rendering or GPU compute and need ECC memory, many drive bays and a full-size Quadro card.
• Choose the HP Elite SFF 600 G9 if you want a small, fast everyday desktop for office work, light photo editing and multitasking on a current platform.