Levi's 501 Original Fit Jeans vs Lucky Brand 410 Athletic Straight Jean

The Levi's 501 is the safer pick for anyone who wants the original straight-leg jean: rigid-feeling 14 oz denim, a button fly, and a shape that has barely changed in decades. The Lucky Brand 410 is the better jean for athletic builds and for anyone who wants stretch and a zip fly, since its Coolmax blend moves more and its roomy straight leg leaves space through the seat and thigh. Owners of the 501 praise the durability and classic look but often mention break-in time and a stiff button fly; 410 owners tend to like the comfort and lighter feel, though the fabric wears softer and less rigid over time.

• Choose the Levi's 501 if you want a stiff, hard-wearing straight-leg jean with a button fly and a fit that has stayed the same for generations.
• Choose the Lucky Brand 410 if you have larger thighs or a seat and want a zip fly with stretch denim that moves with you.