Linenspa Waterproof Mattress Protector vs SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector

Both are waterproof fitted protectors with zippered five-sided coverage, so the real split is fabric and certification. The SafeRest uses a cotton-backed surface, is OEKO-TEX certified, and is the better pick for allergy-sensitive sleepers and households with pets or kids. The Linenspa is a thin polyurethane protector with a 14-inch stretch skirt that fits deep mattresses and is the simpler, lighter choice for basic spill and accident protection. Owners of both report the waterproof layer holds up through repeated washing; the SafeRest feels softer against the skin, while the Linenspa feels more like a plastic sheet.

• Choose the Linenspa if you want a light, thin waterproof layer for deep mattresses and mainly need protection from nighttime accidents and spills.
• Choose the SafeRest if you want a cotton-backed, OEKO-TEX certified protector that sleeps cooler and suits allergy sufferers, kids or pets.