Which is better for a 1-year-old?

The Play For All School, which is rated from 1 year. The Nativity is listed from 1.5 years, though its age range runs to 5.

Which has more pieces?

The Nativity. It has 11 figures and 5 play pieces plus a stable, against 2 figures and 2 play pieces in the School set.

Which one makes sounds?

Only the Nativity. Pressing the angel lights the star and plays Away in the Manger, using 3 AA batteries that are included.

Is the Nativity worth the extra money?

It depends on the season. At its recent low of $49.99 on November 4, you pay for 11 figures, lights and music. The School set has no current price listed here, so check both before deciding.

Which lasts longer as a toy?

The School set, because its school theme works all year. The Nativity tends to come out at Christmas or sit as a display.

Which is easier to store?

The School set. It weighs 0.55 kg and is a single compact playset. The Nativity weighs 2.1 lb and has 11 loose figures plus a stable.

Fisher-Price Little People Play for All School vs Fisher-Price Little People Nativity

Buy the Play For All School for year-round toddler play that builds fine motor skills and storytelling. Buy the Nativity if you want a Christmas-themed set with lights, music and many figures. The Nativity's lowest recent price was $49.99 on November 4, against a high of $54.97 on October 30. No current price was given for the School playset, so compare store prices before you decide.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.