Which is better for dry hands?

The L'Occitane trio. It is a hand cream with 20% shea butter, sized for hands and purses. The Josie Maran kit is a body butter, richer and better suited to elbows, legs and body.

Which lasts longer on the skin?

Josie Maran claims 48 hours of hydration; L'Occitane claims 24 hours. Both are marketing claims, and real wear depends on washing and weather.

Is the Josie Maran kit worth the extra?

It is not extra. It is $36 at Sephora versus $37 for L'Occitane at L'Occitane as of November 7, 2026. Pick by product type, not price.

Can I use the Josie Maran butter on my hands?

Yes, but it is a body butter in 60 ml units, so it is thicker and greasier than a dedicated hand cream. The L'Occitane tubes are easier to carry and reapply.

Which is better for sensitive skin?

L'Occitane is the safer bet on paper: vegan and silicone-free, with a single shea formula. The Josie Maran kit has three scents, and fragrance is a common irritant.

How many pieces do I get in each?

Three in both. L'Occitane gives three 1 oz (30 ml) hand creams; Josie Maran gives three 60 ml body butters in different scents.

L'Occitane Hand Cream Trio vs Josie Maran Butter Babies Kit

Buy the L'Occitane trio if you want hand cream: three 1 oz tubes of 20% shea butter, vegan and silicone-free, at $37 at L'Occitane as of November 7, 2026. Buy the Josie Maran Butter Babies Kit if you want body butter in three scents, at $36 at Sephora as of November 7, 2026. The prices are within a dollar, so the choice comes down to hand cream versus body butter, not cost.

Today the Josie Maran Butter Babies Kit costs $1.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.