Loft Haven Well Within Cashmere Crewneck vs Charter Club Cashmere Brushed Crewneck
Both are casual cashmere crewnecks, so the choice comes down to fit and finish. The Charter Club is 100% cashmere with a brushed hand and comes in five colors, and its lowest recorded price was $128.24 on October 30, 2026. The Loft Haven Well Within is a lighter, more relaxed pullover, but no price was given for it here, so compare its current store price against that $128.24 before deciding. Buy the Charter Club for a classic, warm crewneck; buy the Loft if you want a looser, everyday layer and its price is lower.
Ask our shopping agent
It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.
Loft Haven Well Within Cashmere Crewneck
Loft Haven Well Within Cashmere Crewneck Sweater
Choose the Loft Haven Well Within if you want a relaxed, casual pullover and its current price beats the Charter Club's $128.24.
- Relaxed cut layers easily over shirts
- Simple crewneck works with most outfits
- Light enough for indoor wear
What separates them
| Loft Haven Well Within Cashmere Crewneck | Charter Club Cashmere Brushed Crewneck | |
|---|---|---|
| Fiber content | Cashmere blend, per the Well Within line | 100% cashmere |
| Finish | Smooth knit | Brushed, softer surface |
| Neckline | Crew neck | Round neck, close to crew |
| Color range | Not specified | Five colors, including Purple and Vanilla Ice |
| Fit | Relaxed, casual pullover | Regular fit |
| Price | No price given | $128.24 lowest recorded, October 30, 2026 |
Price history
- Loft Haven Well Within Cashmere Crewneck: lowest $134.88 on Oct 30 at LOFT.
- Charter Club Cashmere Brushed Crewneck: lowest $128.24 on Oct 30 at Macy's; $128.24 on Nov 1.
Prices at every store
Charter Club Cashmere Brushed Crewneck
- Macy'sCheck price at Macy's
- LystCheck price at Lyst
Specs compared
| Spec | Loft Haven Well Within Cashmere Crewneck | Charter Club Cashmere Brushed Crewneck |
|---|---|---|
| Neckline | Crew Neck | Round Neck |
| Style | Pullover | Sweater |
| Occasion | Casual | Casual |
| Sleeve Length | Long Sleeve | — |
| Department | — | Women's |
| Material | — | Cashmere |
| Pattern | — | Solid |
| Sleeve Style | — | Long Sleeve |
| Color | — | Purple, Coffee Bean, Vanilla Ice, Seaside Slate… |
| Size Type | — | Regular |
What reviewers say
Charter Club Cashmere Brushed Crewneck
Buyers of Charter Club cashmere generally praise the softness and warmth for the price, and the brushed finish gets mentioned as a plus. Common complaints are pilling after a few wears and the care needed to keep it looking new.
- SoftnessPraisedOwners describe the brushed cashmere as soft and comfortable to wear all day.
- PillingCriticisedSeveral mention small pills forming after a few wears, especially under the arms.
- WarmthPraisedIt is described as warm for its weight and good for layering in cold weather.
- Care
Questions and answers
- Which is warmer, the Loft or the Charter Club?
- The Charter Club, most likely. It is 100% cashmere with a brushed finish, which traps more air than a lighter blend. The Loft is described as a casual pullover, so treat it as a lighter layer.
- Is the Charter Club worth $128.24?
- That is a fair price for 100% cashmere. Check the Loft's current price first; if it is well under $128.24, the gap may not be worth it.
- Which has more color choices?
- The Charter Club. It comes in Purple, Coffee Bean, Vanilla Ice, Seaside Slate and Pearl Taupe Heather. The Loft listing gives no colors.
- Which fits looser?
- The Loft, which is described as a relaxed casual pullover. The Charter Club is a regular fit, so size up if you want room.
- Will either pill?
- Both can. Brushed cashmere like the Charter Club pills more easily at the underarms and cuffs. Wash cold by hand and dry flat to limit it.