Which is better for a kitchen remodel on a tight timeline?

The Lowe's Project Source cabinet, because it comes fully assembled. The Hampton Bay unit needs ClickReady assembly before it goes on the wall.

Which has a more flexible shelf?

The Hampton Bay cabinet. Its shelf is adjustable, while the Lowe's cabinet has one fixed shelf.

Are either of these moisture resistant?

No. The Lowe's cabinet is listed as not moisture resistant, and the Hampton Bay cabinet is not rated for it. Avoid hanging either directly over a sink or dishwasher.

Can I paint or stain both?

Yes. Both ship unfinished oak, so you can paint, stain or seal them to match your kitchen.

Is the Hampton Bay cabinet worth choosing over the Lowe's one?

If you want an adjustable shelf and don't mind assembly, yes. If you want to skip assembly and get a solid wood face frame, the Lowe's cabinet is the better fit.

Do both fit the same wall space?

Yes. Both are 18 inches wide, 30 inches high and 12 inches deep, so they swap directly.

Lowe's Project Source 18-in W x 30-in H Unfinished Oak Wall Cabinet vs Home Depot Hampton Bay 18 in. W x 30 in. H Assembled Wall Kitchen Cabinet in Unfinished Oak with Adjustable Shelf

Both are 18 x 30 x 12 inch unfinished oak wall cabinets with a single flat-panel door, so the choice comes down to assembly and shelf adjustability. The Lowe's Project Source cabinet arrives fully assembled with a fixed shelf and a solid wood face frame. The Hampton Bay cabinet uses ClickReady assembly and an adjustable shelf, and it carries a 4.6 out of 5 rating from 238 ratings. Check current prices at each store before you buy, since neither price was provided here.

Ask our shopping agent