Lucky Fours Lady Santos vs Tissot Carson Women's Watch

The Tissot Carson is the better watch: Swiss automatic movement, sapphire crystal and a two-tone steel case that holds up for years. The Lucky Fours Lady Santos is a tank-style quartz watch that looks like a luxury design for a fraction of the outlay, but it has no brand heritage and a plainer build. Buy the Tissot for a lasting gift or a daily watch; buy the Lucky Fours if the rectangular tank look matters more than the movement.

• Choose the Lucky Fours Lady Santos if you want the rectangular tank silhouette and a low-commitment fashion watch.
• Choose the Tissot Carson if you want a Swiss automatic with sapphire crystal that will last and look the part as a gift.