Emerald Suede Penny Loafers vs Adler Dark Green Patent Penny Loafers

The Adler is the safer buy for most people: it has a large, strong owner rating, a cushioned memory foam insole, a grippy EVA lug sole and a true-to-size fit, all made in Italy. The Emerald pair is the more distinctive choice, with suede and a gecko emboss and a gum studded sole, but its listing is inconsistent about materials and construction, so you are buying character with less certainty. On build, the Adler's leather sole and stacked heel read dressier, while the Emerald's rubber sole is more casual and weather-friendly.

• Choose the Emerald Penny Loafers if you want a suede statement shoe with an embossed gecko print and a soft gum rubber sole for casual wear.
• Choose the Adler Dark Green Patent Loafers if you want a proven, well-rated patent leather loafer with a cushioned insole and a lug sole that grips.