Ashley Mackmenville Reclining Loveseat vs Derby Reclining Console Loveseat

The Derby is the better pick for most families. It is wider, rated to 500 lbs, and its light gray fabric suits busy rooms. The Mackmenville counters with faux leather that wipes clean, a zero-wall design that saves floor space, and a heavier 192 lb build that feels more substantial. Owners of both report the lever recliners work smoothly; the Mackmenville's one-pull recline is easier for people with weak grip.

• Choose the Mackmenville if you want wipe-clean caramel faux leather, a zero-wall layout for tight rooms, or one-pull reclining that is easier on the hands.
• Choose the Derby if you need a wider seat, a 500 lb weight rating, and soft light gray fabric that hides everyday wear in a family room.