Which ring lasts longer for everyday wear?

The Macy's blue topaz ring. Topaz is much harder than opal, and 14k gold is more durable than 10k. An opal ring is better saved for occasional wear.

Is the Helzberg opal ring worth the extra?

No price was given for the Helzberg ring, so compare it at checkout. The Macy's ring is $555.37 at Macy's as of October 30, 2026, in 14k gold with a harder stone.

Can I get the Macy's ring in my size?

It is listed as one size only. Ask Macy's about resizing before you buy, since sizing a ring can affect the setting.

Which is better for a gift?

The Macy's ring suits daily wear and needs no special care beyond cleaning. The Helzberg opal is the pick for someone who loves opal's color play and will wear it gently.

Does the Helzberg ring come in more sizes?

Yes. It comes in sizes 6, 6½, 7, 7½, 8, 8½ and 9. The Macy's ring is one size only.

How should I care for each?

Clean the topaz ring with mild soap and water, and use Macy's free in-store cleaning. Keep the opal away from water, heat and knocks, and wipe it with a soft cloth.

Macy's Blue Topaz & Diamond Ring vs Helzberg Oval Opal & Diamond Ring

Buy the Macy's blue topaz ring if you want 14k white gold, a harder stone for daily wear, and free in-store cleaning. Buy the Helzberg opal ring if you prefer warm 10k yellow gold and need a specific size from 6 to 9. The Macy's ring has been $555.37 at Macy's since October 30, 2026; no current price was given for the Helzberg ring, so compare it at checkout before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.