Macy's Galligher 82" Leather Sofa vs Crate & Barrel Gather Deep Sofa
The Macy's Galligher is the better buy for most shoppers: it costs $899 at Macy's as of October 30, 2026, versus $1,749 at Crate & Barrel for the Gather Deep Sofa. The Gather wins if you want a deep, low lounge seat (28" seat depth, 19" seat height) and a kiln-dried FSC-certified frame. The Galligher is a taller, firmer, more upright sofa with attached cushions and a lower price.
Ask our shopping agent
Macy's Galligher 82" Leather Sofa
4.4Choose the Macy's Galligher if you want a firm, supportive leather sofa with a 21.65" seat depth and a 35" back for about half the price.
- Lowest price of the two at $899
- Firm, supportive back and seats that hold their shape
- Smooth leather that cleans with a wet rag
- Attached cushions stay in place
- Removable walnut-finish wood legs
- Firmness is too hard for some buyers
- Shallow 21.65" seat depth limits lounging
- Plywood in the frame
What separates them
| Macy's Galligher 82" Leather Sofa | Crate & Barrel Gather Deep Sofa | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $899 at Macy's as of October 30, 2026 | $1,749 at Crate & Barrel as of October 30, 2026 |
| Overall size | 82"W x 37"D x 35"H | 89"W x 43"D x 26"H |
| Seat depth | 21.65" | 28" |
| Seat height | Not listed; 35" overall height suggests a taller, more upright seat | 19" |
| Cushion construction | 2.5 lb. density foam with Dacron wrap, fiber; attached cushions | Innerspring wrapped in polyfoam with fiber; fiber-filled back cushions |
| Frame | Plywood and hardwood, corner blocked, dowelled and bolted | Kiln-dried wood and FSC-certified engineered hardwood |
| Suspension | Heavy-duty elastic webbing | Sinuous wire springs |
Price history
- Macy's Galligher 82" Leather Sofa: lowest $899.00 on Oct 30 at Macy's; $899.00 on Oct 31.
- Crate & Barrel Gather Deep Sofa: lowest $1,749.00 on Oct 30 at crateandbarrel.com; $1,749.00 on Nov 2.
Prices at every store
Crate & Barrel Gather Deep Sofa
- crateandbarrel.comCheck price at crateandbarrel.com
- ModeSensCheck price at ModeSens
Specs compared
| Spec | Macy's Galligher 82" Leather Sofa | Crate & Barrel Gather Deep Sofa |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Material | Leather | Leather |
| Depth | 37" | 43" |
| Length | 82" | 89" |
| Overall Dimensions | 82"W x 37"D x 35"H | 26" H x 89" W x 43" D |
| Height | 35" | 26" H |
| Seat Depth | 21.65" | 28.0 |
| Seat Dimensions | 25" arm | Width: 81.0, Depth: 28.0 |
| Frame Material | Plywood, Hardwood | Kiln-dried wood, FSC®-certified engineered hard… |
| Number Of Pieces | 1 | 1 |
| Fabric Type | Leather | Leather |
What reviewers say
Macy's Galligher 82" Leather Sofa
Rated 4.4 out of 5 from 43 ratings, the Galligher draws praise for build quality, looks and supportive firmness. The main complaint is that the seat is harder than expected, with one owner calling it very uncomfortable despite its appearance.
- Overall quality and attractive appearance
- Comfortable, supportive firmness
- Soft, smooth leather of good quality
- Holds its shape and gives good back support
- Some find the firmness too hard
- One reviewer found it very uncomfortable despite looking nice
Crate & Barrel Gather Deep Sofa
Owners describe the Gather Deep Sofa as firm but extremely comfortable, with the deep seat and solid construction standing out. Feedback on the upholstery is mixed: some call it durable, soft and easy to clean, while one long-term owner reports stretching and wear.
Questions and answers
- Which is better for lounging?
- The Gather Deep Sofa. Its 28" seat depth and 19" seat height let you curl up; the Galligher's 21.65" seat depth is more upright.
- Is the Gather worth $850 more?
- If you want a deep lounge seat and an FSC-certified kiln-dried frame, yes. If you want a firm, supportive sofa at a lower price, the Galligher is enough.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Gather has the sturdier spec sheet: innerspring cushions and sinuous wire springs. The Galligher uses foam cushions on elastic webbing. Both depend on use.
- Which is better for a small room?
- The Galligher. At 82"W x 37"D it takes less floor space than the Gather at 89"W x 43"D.
- Is the Galligher too firm?
- Some buyers say so. Reviews call it firm and supportive, and a few found it too hard or uncomfortable.
- Does either come in other fabrics?
- The Gather does, with multiple fabric and arm options and free swatches. The Galligher is listed only in smooth leather.
More comparisons
- 4-Seat Modular Sofa vs Crate & Barrel Gather Deep Sofa
- Macy 6-Seat U-Shaped Modular Sofa vs Crate & Barrel Gather Deep Sofa
- OVIOS U-Shaped Modular Sectional Sofa vs Crate & Barrel Gather Deep Sofa
- Crate & Barrel Gather Deep Sofa vs Albany Park Kova Sofa
- Macy's Myriem 87" Fabric Sofa vs Crate & Barrel Gather Deep Sofa
- Macy's Galligher 82" Leather Sofa vs Macy's Cobbie Leather 89" Sofa
- Macy's Myriem 87" Fabric Sofa vs Macy's Galligher 82" Leather Sofa
- Macy's Cobbie Leather 89" Sofa vs Crate & Barrel Gather Deep Sofa