Kiyonna Mademoiselle Lace Cocktail Dress vs Maggie Glitter Fit & Flare Mini Dress

Buy the Kiyonna Mademoiselle if you want a plus-size midi that covers the shoulders and holds up over years of events. Its scalloped lace, 3/4 sleeves and heavy US-made fabric draw consistent praise from owners in sizes up to 5X, and the fit-and-flare cut is called flattering and true to the size chart. The Maggie is the pick for a shorter, sparklier party look: a structured corset bodice, puffed sleeves and glitter fabric in a machine-washable EcoVero viscose. It is imported, runs to a semi-slim fit, and the glitter sheds, so it suits a single big night more than a long wardrobe life.

• Choose the Mademoiselle if you want a plus-size midi with sleeves, dry-clean construction and a fit owners call reliably true to size.
• Choose the Maggie if you want a short, glittery fit-and-flare with a structured corset bodice for homecoming or a party.