Black FridayDealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

Magical Athlete vs Quacks

Buy Magical Athlete for family game nights with younger kids: it plays in 30 minutes, handles up to 6 players, and costs $27.19 at CMYK as of November 5, 2026. Buy Quacks for older players who want a real strategy game with push-your-luck tension; it runs about 45 minutes for 2-4 players and costs $39.99 at CMYK as of the same date. Magical Athlete is the cheaper and more accessible pick, while Quacks gives a deeper, more replayable game for the extra $12.80.

Today the Magical Athlete costs $12.80 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

M
Magical Athlete

Magical Athlete

4.9· 103 ratings
$27.19at CMYKObserved at 2:34 AM
Visit store

Choose the Magical Athlete if you need a fast, loud game for a mixed-age family table of up to 6 players and want to spend under $30.

Pros
  • Plays in about 30 minutes, easy to fit into a weeknight
  • Seats up to 6 players, good for larger families
  • Simple die-roll movement that a 6-year-old can follow
  • Variable racer powers keep rounds unpredictable
  • Lowest price of the two at $27.19
Cons
  • Luck-heavy, with little long-term strategy
  • Racer powers are deliberately unbalanced
  • No expansions or deluxe upgrade path
  • Best with a group that tolerates chaos
Q
Quacks

Quacks

5· 2 ratings
$39.99at CMYKObserved at 7:02 AM
Visit store

Choose the Quacks if your group is 10 and up and wants a strategic bag-building game with luck-pushing and expansion options.

Pros
  • Bag-building and push-your-luck give real decisions each turn
  • Wolfgang Warsch design with strong replay value
  • Deluxe and All-In editions add bakelite tiles and both expansions
  • All-In Edition raises the player count to 5
Cons
  • Costs $39.99, about $12.80 more than Magical Athlete
  • Needs players 10 and up
  • 45-minute games are long for younger kids
  • Base game caps at 4 players unless you buy All-In

What separates them

Magical AthleteQuacks
Recommended age6+10+
Player count2-62-4 (5 with All-In Edition)
Play timeAbout 30 minutesAbout 45 minutes
Core mechanicRoll a die and move, with unfair racer powersDraw ingredients from a bag and push your luck
Strategy depthLight and chaotic, luck-drivenDeeper, with bag-building and risk management
Price$27.19 at CMYK as of November 5, 2026$39.99 at CMYK as of November 5, 2026
EditionsSingle standard editionStandard, Deluxe and All-In editions
ExpansionsNoneThe Witches and The Alchemists included in All-In

Price history

  • Magical Athlete: lowest $26.99 on Nov 3 at Rainbow Resource Center.
  • Quacks: lowest $39.99 on Nov 3 at Amazon.

Prices at every store

Magical Athlete

  • CMYKNew

    Availability unknownReturn policy

    $27.19Observed at 2:34 AM
    Visit store

Also available at

  • CMYKCheck price at CMYK
  • eBayCheck price at eBay
  • Greenfield GamesCheck price at Greenfield Games
Prices and history →

Quacks

  • CMYKNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $39.99Observed at 7:02 AM
    Visit store

Also available at

  • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
  • PoshmarkCheck price at Poshmark
Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecMagical AthleteQuacks
Recommended Age6+10+ Years
Play Time30 minutes60 minutes
Playing Time30'45 minutes
LanguageJapanese (original game)—
MaterialWood (dice)—
Maximum Players6—
Minimum Players2—
Game ModeCompetitive—
Included AccessoriesCards, Board—
Game CompatibilityCosmic Encounter (inspiration)—
OccasionGame table—
Count4 (characters per player)—
Show all 36 specsShow fewer specs
SpecMagical AthleteQuacks
Dice ShapeSix-sided die—
Dice SpecialtyWooden—
Character NameDuelist—
Typical UsersFamily—
Release DateQ1 2026 (EU new orders), 2025-12 (LATE DECEMBER)—
Packaging TypeBox—
Players2-6—
Age6+—
LanguagesEnglish—
Dimensions19.9cm (H) x 30.8cm (W) x 5.3cm (D)

What reviewers say

Magical Athlete

Rated 4.9 out of 5 from 103 ratings. Owners treat it as a light, funny party racer rather than a strategy game, and the absurd racers and unfair powers are the draw.

Pros
  • Racer powers are funny and create big swings
  • Easy enough for young kids to play unaided
  • Short 30-minute length suits a game night opener
  • Art and components feel polished
Cons
  • Luck can decide the race regardless of play
  • Some powers feel far stronger than others
  • Repeat plays can feel samey for heavier gamers

Quacks

Reception is thin so far, with a 5 out of 5 from 2 ratings. The game is widely regarded as one of the better push-your-luck designs of recent years, praised for tension and accessibility.

Pros
  • Tense push-your-luck decisions every turn
  • Easy to teach and quick to play
  • Rewards build in a satisfying way
Cons
  • Draw luck can decide games
  • Explosions feel punishing for younger players

Questions and answers

Which is better for a family with young kids?
Magical Athlete. It is rated 6+, plays in 30 minutes, and seats up to 6. Quacks is rated 10+ and takes about 45 minutes.
Is Quacks worth the extra $12.80?
If your group is 10 and up and wants real strategy, yes. Quacks adds bag-building decisions and expansion content that Magical Athlete does not have.
Which works better for two players?
Both play at two. Magical Athlete is lighter and faster at 30 minutes; Quacks gives a more tactical two-player duel at about 45 minutes.
Which has more replay value?
Quacks. The ingredient effects vary each game, and the All-In Edition adds two expansions. Magical Athlete is chaotic but has a single fixed set of racers.
How many players does each handle?
Magical Athlete handles 2-6 out of the box. Quacks handles 2-4 in the Standard and Deluxe editions, and 5 with the All-In Edition.
Which is easier to teach new players?
Magical Athlete. You roll a die and move; each racer's power is the only wrinkle. Quacks needs explaining bag draws, cauldron placement and explosion rules.

More comparisons

  • Finspan vs Quacks
  • Finspan vs Magical Athlete

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best toys
—
Min. Number of Players2 players—
Year2025—
Genre—Strategy
Max Players—4 Player
Age Group—Kids
Family Friendly—Yes
Min Players—2 players or more
Player count—2 - 5
Recommended ages—10+
Publisher—CMYK
Designer—Wolfgang Warsch
Artist—Ryogo Toyoda
Year published—2025
Game type—Competitive