Magicycle 20" Fat Tire Ebike SUV vs Addmotor Soletan M-66X

The Magicycle is the stronger pick for most riders: a 750W motor with 100Nm of torque, a 52V 20Ah battery, 28 MPH pedal-assist top speed and a 450 lb capacity beat the Soletan M-66X on power and payload. The Addmotor is the calmer, retro-styled cruiser with puncture-resistant fat tires and water-resistant wiring, but its 20 MPH limit and 300 lb capacity suit gentler riding. Both are heavy, full-suspension fat-tire bikes, so expect to store them with room and lift them with care. Owners of the Magicycle praise hill climbing, range and easy assembly; the Soletan's appeal is mostly its 1970s look and relaxed ride.

• Choose the Magicycle if you want more power, more range and a higher weight limit for hills, off-road riding or carrying gear.
• Choose the Addmotor Soletan M-66X if you want a retro-styled step-thru cruiser for paved paths and light trails and don't need Class 3 speed.