Magnavox Ice Cream & Frozen Slush Drink Maker vs GreenPan Frost Ice Cream Maker

Both are self-cooling 2-quart machines that make ice cream and frozen drinks without pre-freezing a bowl. The GreenPan Frost is the stronger all-rounder: a built-in compressor chills from scratch, churns in as little as 15 minutes, and its 275 ratings give a much larger track record than the Magnavox's 14. The Magnavox adds a spiked-slush and frappe mode, 10 texture levels and a quieter 54 dB rating, but its 40-minute ice cream cycle is slower and its user base is thin. Buy the GreenPan for reliability and speed; buy the Magnavox if quiet operation and drink variety matter more than a proven record.

• Choose the Magnavox if you want a quieter machine with more texture settings and drink modes like frappe and frozen juice, and you can accept a slower 40-minute ice cream cycle.
• Choose the GreenPan Frost if you want a proven self-cooling machine that churns in about 15 minutes and has a large body of owner feedback behind it.