Which cover is better for cold weather?

The RV Parts Giant cover, on paper. It states thick cotton padding and a waterproof backing, which helps against damp and drafts. The other cover lists cotton padding but no waterproof layer.

Do both fit a 30 x 79 in door?

Yes. Both are sized for frames up to 30 x 79 in, measured excluding the frame. The Magnetic RV Door Cover gives a curtain size of about 33 x 80 in, so check clearance around the frame.

Which is easier to install?

The RV Parts Giant cover, because it names its mounting: hook-and-loop fasteners, adhesive tape and optional nails. The other cover says no assembly is required but does not describe how it attaches.

Hard to say from the listings. Both use Oxford fabric and cotton padding, and on covers like these the magnets and seams wear first. The waterproof backing on the RV Parts Giant cover may slow fabric breakdown from rain.

Is the RV Parts Giant cover worth stepping up to?

If you camp in wet or cold conditions, yes. The stated waterproof backing and included mounting hardware are real differences. In dry, mild weather the two covers are close to the same product.

Magnetic Insulated RV Door Cover vs RV Insulated Door Cover with Magnetic Closure

These are near-identical products: both are Oxford fabric door covers with cotton padding sized for 30 x 79 in frames, and both close magnetically. The RV Parts Giant cover is the clearer buy because its listing spells out a waterproof backing, hook-and-loop plus adhesive mounting, and optional nails, while the other cover's listing is thin on construction detail. Owners of this style of cover report the magnets and seams are the first things to wear, so check fit and mounting before you commit.

Choose the Magnetic RV Door Cover if you want the plain insulated magnetic cover and the listing's buyer feedback on packaging and delivery speed matters to you.
Choose the RV Parts Giant Insulated Door Cover if you want a stated waterproof backing and a mounting kit with hook-and-loop, adhesive tape and optional nails.

Prices

Magnetic Insulated RV Door Cover: $29.99 at Amazon (last seen Nov 9)
RV Insulated Door Cover with Magnetic Closure: $53.99 at eBay (last seen Nov 9)
Difference: the Magnetic Insulated RV Door Cover is $24.00 cheaper than the RV Insulated Door Cover with Magnetic Closure at the latest prices (Nov 9)

	Magnetic Insulated RV Door Cover	RV Insulated Door Cover with Magnetic Closure
Door frame fit	Up to 30 x 79 in, curtain about 33 x 80 in	30 x 79 in frame, excluding frame
Fabric and padding	Oxford fabric with cotton padding	Heavy-duty Oxford fabric with thick cotton padding
Waterproofing	Not stated	Waterproof backing
Mounting	Not detailed in the listing	Hook-and-loop fasteners plus adhesive tape, optional nails included
Closure	Magnetic	Magnetic
Assembly	None required	None required beyond mounting
Color and sizing detail	Black, curtain dimensions given	Color not stated
Buyer feedback on record	Buyers praise packaging and fast shipping; some report slow delivery	No owner feedback on record

Spec	Magnetic Insulated RV Door Cover	RV Insulated Door Cover with Magnetic Closure
Material	Oxford fabric with cotton padding	Oxford fabric with cotton padding
Fits door frames up to	30″ × 79″ (excluding frame)	—
Unit Count	1.0 Count	—
Item Length	1	—
Smart Home Compatibility	Not Smart Home Compatible	—
Operation Mode	Manual	—
Required Assembly	No	—
Item Height	1	—
Item Width	1	—
Door frame fit	—	30″ × 79″ (excluding frame)
Closure type	—	magnetic closure
Padding	—	Thick cotton padding

Spec	Magnetic Insulated RV Door Cover	RV Insulated Door Cover with Magnetic Closure
Fabric	—	heavy-duty Oxford fabric
Backing	—	waterproof backing
Installation	—	hook-and-loop fasteners and adhesive tape
Included hardware	—	optional nails included

Magnetic Insulated RV Door Cover vs RV Insulated Door Cover with Magnetic Closure

Prices

Magnetic Insulated RV Door Cover vs RV Insulated Door Cover with Magnetic Closure

Prices

Magnetic Insulated RV Door Cover

RV Insulated Door Cover with Magnetic Closure

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store

Magnetic Insulated RV Door Cover

RV Insulated Door Cover with Magnetic Closure

Specs compared

What reviewers say

Magnetic Insulated RV Door Cover

Questions and answers

Ask our shopping agent

Buying guides that pick them