Mainstays 10-Tier Shoe Rack with Cover vs SONGMICS 10-Tier Shoe Tower Rack

Buy the SONGMICS if you want a narrow, steel-tube rack that can split into two 5-tier units and has shelves you can pull out for tall boots. Buy the Mainstays if you want a wider, fully covered rack that holds more pairs and hides clutter in an entryway. The SONGMICS is the sturdier, more flexible build; the Mainstays wins on capacity and looks. Owners of both report the fabric covers are thin and the racks need careful assembly, and neither is furniture-grade.

• Choose the Mainstays if you need to store up to 30 pairs out of sight in a wide entryway or closet and want a full zip-down cover.
• Choose the SONGMICS if floor space is tight, you want a steel frame that splits into two racks, or you need adjustable shelf heights for boots.