StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Mattress Protector vs Quilted Pillow Top Mattress Topper

Buy the Mainstays if your main goal is protecting the mattress from spills, allergens and bacteria; its TPU backing and antimicrobial treatment are the real protection here. Buy the quilted pillow top if you want to soften a firm mattress and add a plush comfort layer. The Mainstays is a thin, cool-to-touch barrier with a strong 4.3 rating from over 2,500 owners; the quilted topper is a comfort pad whose waterproofing and allergen claims are weaker and less documented.

  • Choose the Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Fitted Mattress Protector if you need a genuinely waterproof, allergen-blocking barrier that stays cool and washes easily.
  • Choose the quilted pillow top topper if your mattress is too firm and you want a plusher, hotel-style sleep surface with a deep pocket that fits thick mattresses.

Prices

  • Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Mattress Protector: $30.64 at Walmart (checked today)
  • Quilted Pillow Top Mattress Topper: $53.99 at Home Viaco (checked today)
  • Difference: the Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Mattress Protector is $23.35 cheaper than the Quilted Pillow Top Mattress Topper today
Mainstays
Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Fitted Mattress Protector

Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Mattress Protector

Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Fitted Mattress Protector

4.3(2,539 ratings)
$30.64at WalmartChecked 51 min ago
See all prices and details
Visit Walmart
Pros
  • Waterproof TPU backing shields the mattress from spills
  • Allergen barrier and antimicrobial treatment
  • Cool-to-touch surface for hot sleepers
  • Fitted stretch sidewalls go on and off quickly
  • Large base of owner ratings
Cons
  • Thin, so it adds no cushioning
  • Fits mattresses only up to about 15 in
  • White only
M
Mattress Topper Quilted Pillow Top Mattress Pad Cover, Fitted Mattress Protector 8-21" Deep Pocket Cooling

Quilted Pillow Top Mattress Topper

Mattress Topper Quilted Pillow Top Mattress Pad Cover, Fitted Mattress Protector 8-21" Deep Pocket Cooling

5(3 ratings)
$53.99at Home ViacoChecked 1 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Home Viaco
Pros
  • Quilted pillow top adds real plushness
  • Deep pocket fits mattresses from 8 to 21 in
  • Breathable cooling fabric
  • Stays put without bunching
  • Machine washable
Cons
  • No stated waterproof layer
  • No allergen or antimicrobial claims
  • Thicker pad can sleep warmer than a thin cover
  • Little owner rating data to judge durability

What separates them

Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Mattress ProtectorQuilted Pillow Top Mattress Topper
Primary purposeWaterproof barrier that protects the mattressComfort pad that softens the sleep surface
WaterproofingTPU-coated face blocks spills and stainsQuilted fabric with no stated waterproof layer
Allergen and antimicrobialMarketed as allergen barrier and antimicrobialNot specified
Surface feelThin, smooth, cool-to-touchPlush quilted pillow top
Fit depthFits mattresses up to about 15 inDeep pocket stretches to fit 8 to 21 in
CoolingCooling face coatingBreathable cooling fabric
Owner feedback4.3 of 5 from 2,539 ratingsNo comparable rating volume given
CareMachine washableMachine washable

Prices at every store

Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Mattress Protector

  • WalmartNew

    In stock

    $30.64Checked 51 min ago
    Visit Walmart
Prices and history →

Quilted Pillow Top Mattress Topper

  • Home ViacoNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $53.99Checked 1 h ago
    Visit Home Viaco
Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecMainstays Cooling Waterproof Mattress ProtectorQuilted Pillow Top Mattress Topper
bed_sizeQueen—
sizeQueen—
multipack_quantity1—
colorWhite—
TypeMattress Protector—
Protection PropertiesWaterproof, Allergen Barrier, Antimicrobial—
Length75 in—
Thickness15 in (fits most mattresses)—
Care InstructionsMachine Washable—
Closure TypeFitted Sheet Style—
StyleFitted—
Solution ForAllergies, Odor-causing bacteria, Spills and st…—

What reviewers say

Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Mattress Protector

  • 4.3 / 52,539 ratings

Owners rate it 4.3 out of 5 across more than 2,500 ratings. Most praise the easy fit and reliable spill protection for the money. Complaints center on the cooling effect wearing off and a tight fit on deep mattresses.

What people mention
  • CoolingMixedSome sleepers feel a cool touch at first, but others say it fades quickly.
  • WaterproofingPraisedOwners report spills and accidents stay off the mattress.
  • FitMixedStretch sidewalls go on easily, but the fit is snug on thicker mattresses.
  • FeelPraisedThe top is soft and not plasticky against the skin.

Questions and answers

Which one actually protects the mattress from spills?
The Mainstays. Its TPU-coated face is a waterproof barrier. The quilted topper is a comfort pad and does not state a waterproof layer.
Which is better for a hot sleeper?
Both claim cooling. The Mainstays is thin and cool to the touch, so it traps less heat. The quilted pad adds loft, which usually sleeps warmer.
Will the quilted topper fit a thick mattress?
Yes. Its deep pocket stretches to fit mattresses from 8 to 21 inches. The Mainstays fits up to about 15 inches.
Can I use both together?
Yes. Put the waterproof Mainstays directly on the mattress, then the quilted topper over it for comfort.
Which lasts longer?
The Mainstays has a large track record of owner ratings and a simple thin build. The quilted pad has little durability feedback, and quilting can flatten with washing.
Is the quilted topper worth stepping up to?
Only if you want softness. It does not replace a waterproof protector, so most shoppers still need the Mainstays underneath.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Fitted Mattress Protector vs Cooling Mattress Protector
  • Luxury Cooling Mattress Protector vs Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Fitted Mattress Protector
  • Cozy Earth Cooling Mattress Protector Twin vs Mainstays Cooling Waterproof Fitted Mattress Protector
  • Cozy Earth Cooling Mattress Protector Twin vs Mattress Topper Quilted Pillow Top Mattress Pad Cover, Fitted Mattress Protector 8-21" Deep Pocket Cooling

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best cooling mattress protectors