StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Candle vs Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie Large Jar

Buy the Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie if you want the longest burn and the strongest throw; its 22 oz large jar runs up to 150 hours and owners rate it highly. Buy the Mainstays Cozy Comfort if you want a softer, musk-vanilla-jasmine scent in a lidded decorative jar that suits a table or shelf. The Yankee is the better-built, longer-lasting candle; the Mainstays is the tidier display piece with a milder, everyday fragrance.

  • Choose the Mainstays Cozy Comfort if you want a soft vanilla, jasmine and musk scent in a lidded white textured jar you can leave out on display.
  • Choose the Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie if you want a big, long-burning jar with a strong bakery scent that fills a room.

Prices

  • Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Candle: $4.97 at Walmart (checked today)
  • Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie Large Jar: $14.99 at Amazon (last seen Nov 16)
  • Difference: the Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Candle is $10.02 cheaper than the Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie Large Jar at the latest prices (Nov 16 and Nov 17)
Mainstays
Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Textured Wrapped Scented Candle, 14 oz

Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Candle

Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Textured Wrapped Scented Candle, 14 oz

4.5(3,306 ratings)
$4.97at WalmartChecked 1 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Walmart
Pros
  • Three wicks give an even burn across the jar
  • Metal lid keeps the wax clean and the jar display-ready
  • Soft vanilla, jasmine and musk suits everyday rooms
  • Compact 4-inch jar fits shelves and side tables
Cons
  • About 65 hours of burn, less than half the Yankee
  • Milder scent that won't fill a large open room
  • Paraffin wax with no low-soot claim
Yankee Candle
Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie Original Large Jar Candles 22 oz

Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie Large Jar

Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie Original Large Jar Candles 22 oz

4.7(1,075 ratings)
$14.99at AmazonChecked 13 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Amazon

Store links may earn us a commission. As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

Pros
  • Up to 150 hours of burn from one jar
  • Strong, recognizable Christmas Cookie fragrance
  • Wax formulated for less soot and tunneling
  • Long track record and high owner ratings
Cons
  • Single wick can tunnel if not burned long enough
  • No lid, so dust settles on the wax between uses
  • Bakery scent is sweet and seasonal, not neutral
  • Large jar takes up more shelf space

What separates them

Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick CandleYankee Candle Christmas Cookie Large Jar
Burn timeAbout 65 hoursUp to 150 hours
Wick countThree wicks for a wide, even melt poolSingle wick in the original large jar
Scent profileSoft musk, vanilla and jasmineSweet Christmas Cookie bakery scent
Size14 oz, 4 in wide and 3.75 in tall22 oz large jar
LidMetal lid included for display and dust coverGlass jar, no display lid
WaxParaffin waxWax blend formulated for less soot and tunneling
Scent strengthMilder, layered everyday fragranceStrong room-filling throw
Owner ratings4.5 out of 5 from about 3,300 ratings4.7 out of 5 from about 1,075 ratings on this listing, higher across the line

Price history

$17.49$3.96
Nov 2Nov 17
  • Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Candle: lowest $3.96 on Nov 2 at Walmart; $4.97 on Nov 11.
  • Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie Large Jar: lowest $6.99 on Nov 16 at eBay; $14.99 on Nov 17.

Prices at every store

Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Candle

  • WalmartNew

    In stock

    $4.97Checked 1 h ago
    Visit Walmart
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $4.97+ $19.99 shippingChecked Nov 11
    Visit Amazon
  • PoshmarkNew

    Availability unknown

    $7.00Checked Nov 2
    Visit Poshmark

Also available at

  • WalmartCheck price at Walmart
  • eBayCheck price at eBay
  • Newegg.comCheck price at Newegg.com

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 2 stores and price history →

Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie Large Jar

  • WalmartNew

    In stockSold by Lakeside ShipperReturns: Sold by a Walmart Marketplace seller; returns go to the seller under the seller's returns policy.

    $37.99Checked 1 h ago
    Visit Walmart
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $14.99Checked 13 h ago
    Visit Amazon

Also available at

  • Alibaba.comCheck price at Alibaba.com
  • Blain's Farm & FleetCheck price at Blain's Farm & Fleet
  • eBayCheck price at eBay

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 2 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecMainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick CandleYankee Candle Christmas Cookie Large Jar
colorWhiteCream
size14 Ounce22 oz
ScentCranberryChristmas Cookie
multipack_quantity1—
TypeJar—
ScentedYes—
SeasonFall—
Diameter (")4.0—
Width (")4.0—
Weight (oz)14.0—
Height (")3.75—
Qty. Products in Set (pcs)1—
Show all 16 specsShow fewer specs
SpecMainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick CandleYankee Candle Christmas Cookie Large Jar
Depth (")4.0—
MaterialMetal, Paraffin Wax—
Burn Time (h)65.0—
FragranceMusk, Vanilla, Jasmine—

What reviewers say

Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Candle

  • 4.5 / 53,306 ratings

Buyers rate it highly overall, with 4.5 out of 5 across 3,306 ratings. Most praise the soft vanilla-jasmine scent and the decorative lidded jar for the money. Complaints center on scent strength and burn evenness.

What people mention
  • ScentPraisedBuyers describe a soft vanilla, jasmine and musk blend that suits everyday rooms.
  • ValuePraisedOwners say the 14 oz three-wick jar is a lot of candle for the money.
  • Scent throwMixedSome find the fragrance fills a room; others say it is faint in larger spaces.
  • Burn timeCriticisedThree wicks burn the wax faster than buyers expected.

Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie Large Jar

  • 4.7 / 51,075 ratings

Owners rate it highly and call it a cozy holiday staple, with the vanilla-cookie scent the main draw. Complaints center on weak throw in big rooms and uneven burning when wicks are neglected.

What people mention
  • ScentPraisedOwners describe a warm vanilla and butter cookie smell that fills a room during the holidays.
  • ThrowMixedSome say it scents a small room well; others find it faint in open spaces.
  • BurnCriticisedSeveral report tunneling or soot when wicks are not trimmed each burn.
  • Seasonal appealPraised

Questions and answers

Which candle lasts longer?
The Yankee Candle. Its large jar is rated for up to 150 hours, while the Mainstays 14 oz candle is rated for about 65 hours.
Which has a stronger scent?
The Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie throws noticeably stronger and fills a room. The Mainstays is a softer musk, vanilla and jasmine blend better suited to small spaces.
Is the Mainstays candle good for a bedroom?
Yes. Its milder scent and three-wick even burn work well in a bedroom or small living room, and the lid keeps it tidy on a nightstand.
Does the Yankee Candle tunnel?
It can if you trim the wick and burn it long enough each time to melt the wax to the edge. Yankee says its current wax is formulated to reduce tunneling and soot.
Is the Yankee worth stepping up to?
If you want maximum burn time and a strong seasonal scent, yes. If you want a decorative lidded jar with a subtle everyday fragrance, the Mainstays fits better.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Textured Wrapped Scented Candle, 14 oz vs Teakwood High Intensity 3-Wick 14.5oz Candle
  • Teakwood High Intensity 3-Wick 14.5oz Candle vs Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie Original Large Jar Candles 22 oz
  • Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Textured Wrapped Scented Candle, 14 oz vs Scented Soy Wax Candle
  • Yankee Candle Christmas Cookie Original Large Jar Candles 22 oz vs Scented Soy Wax Candle
  • Goose Creek 3-Wick Warm & Welcome Scented Jar Candle, 14.5oz. vs Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Textured Wrapped Scented Candle, 14 oz
  • Mainstays Starlit Skies 3-Wick Textured Wrapped Scented Jar Candle, 14 oz vs Mainstays Cozy Comfort 3-Wick Textured Wrapped Scented Candle, 14 oz

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best scented jar candles
Buyers treat it as a yearly holiday tradition and repurchase it.