Which is better for silk and strappy dresses?

The Simplify velvet hangers. The velvet coating grips slippery fabric and the contoured shape holds straps, while smooth plastic lets them slide.

Which is better for coats and heavy jackets?

The Mainstays plastic hangers. Rigid polypropylene holds a heavy coat's weight better than a slim velvet hanger, which can flex and lose shape.

Mainstays plastic is wipe-clean and does not wear out from moisture. Velvet coating can mat, spot or peel over years of use, especially with damp clothes.

Is the Simplify pack worth it if it costs more per hanger?

Yes if you hang delicate or slippery clothes, since the grip is the point. If you just need volume for everyday shirts, the Mainstays 50-pack is cheaper per hanger.

Can I use either for damp laundry?

Use the Mainstays hangers. Plastic wipes clean and handles moisture; velvet can stain and lose its grip when wet.

How much closet space does each save?

The Simplify hangers are 0.16 in thick, so they fit noticeably more garments on the same rod. Mainstays hangers are standard thickness and take more room per item.

Mainstays Plastic Clothes Hangers, White, 50-Pack vs Simplify Slim Velvet Plastic Clothes Hangers, 25 Count

Buy the Mainstays 50-pack if you want cheap, sturdy everyday hangers for shirts, coats and damp laundry. Buy the Simplify velvet 25-pack if you hang silky, strappy or delicate clothes and want them not to slide off. The Mainstays pack is $19.65 at Amazon as of November 4, 2026, about 39 cents a hanger. The Simplify pack is $11.52 at The Home Depot as of November 4, 2026, about 46 cents a hanger.

Today the Simplify Slim Velvet Plastic Clothes Hangers, 25 Count costs $8.13 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent