Mainstays Traditional Gray Shag Rug vs Mainstays Dylan Solid Diamond Olefin Area Rug

Both are 5' x 7' Mainstays rugs with similar ratings, so the choice comes down to texture and upkeep. The Traditional Gray Shag is the softer, warmer pick for a bedroom or living room where bare feet matter, but shag pile traps crumbs and pet hair and needs spot or professional cleaning. The Dylan's olefin loop is flatter, easier to vacuum, and has a skid-resistant latex backing, which suits hallways, kitchens and homes with pets or kids. Owners of both rate them about the same; the Dylan edges ahead on durability and staying put.

• Choose the Mainstays Traditional Gray Shag if you want a plush, cozy floor underfoot in a bedroom or living room and don't mind more careful cleaning.
• Choose the Mainstays Dylan Solid Diamond Olefin Blue if you need a low-pile rug that vacuums easily, resists slipping and holds up in a busy hallway, kitchen or pet household.