Malibu Naples 72" Drop-In Bathtub vs Kohler Windward 72" Drop-In Bath

The Kohler Windward is the better tub for most people. It is wider, has a deeper 15-inch water depth, molded lumbar support and integrated armrests, and it carries Kohler's name and CSA/ASTM compliance. The Malibu Naples holds more water to the overflow and has two backrests with a center drain, so it suits a narrower alcove and two bathers facing each other. Both are acrylic drop-ins with similar build quality; the Windward is the more comfortable soak, the Naples the more flexible fit.

• Choose the Malibu Naples if your cutout is tight, you want a center drain with two backrests, or you plan to under-mount the tub.
• Choose the Kohler Windward if you have the deck space for a 42-inch-wide tub and want armrests, lumbar support and a reversible drain.