Which is better for oily skin?

Both are oil-free. The Neutrogena adds a non-comedogenic label, which matters if you clog easily. The Mario Badescu is a cream, so it feels heavier than the gel.

Which is better for sensitive skin?

The Mario Badescu names sensitive skin and uses allantoin to soothe. Lemongrass extract can still sting reactive skin. Patch test either one first.

Which gives more product for the money?

The Mario Badescu is 2 oz versus 1.7 oz for the Neutrogena. The Neutrogena has sold for $12.00 to $17.52 since November 3, 2026; no Mario Badescu price was given, so check both at checkout.

Is the Neutrogena worth the extra if it costs more?

Only if you want hyaluronic acid and a non-comedogenic gel. If you want a soothing cream and more ounces, the Mario Badescu is the better fit.

Can I use either under makeup?

The Neutrogena gel absorbs fast and sits well under makeup on oily skin. The Mario Badescu cream is lightweight but richer, so use less if your foundation pills.

The Mario Badescu has 0.3 oz more product. The gel is easy to over-apply from a jar, so the Neutrogena may run out sooner with daily use.

Mario Badescu Oil Free Moisturizer vs Neutrogena Hydro Boost Water Gel

Choose the Mario Badescu if you have oily, combination or sensitive skin and want a light cream with allantoin to calm redness. Choose the Neutrogena Hydro Boost if you want a water gel with hyaluronic acid and a non-comedogenic label for normal-to-oily skin. The Neutrogena has ranged from $12.00 to $17.52 since November 3, 2026, so its current price is worth checking against that band. No price was given for the Mario Badescu, so compare it at the register before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.