Mariska Bootie vs Elegantia Goods Comfort Platform Loafers

These are not really the same kind of shoe. The Mariska Bootie is a black faux-suede ankle boot with a synthetic insole and outsole, built for a sleeker, closed look. The Elegantia Goods platform loafers are slip-on chunky-heel shoes in PU leather, offered in wide widths and seven colors. Buy the bootie for a dressier, more fitted ankle silhouette; buy the loafers for an easy slip-on with a low platform and wide sizing. Owners of platform styles like this tend to praise the cushioning and stability; faux-suede boots draw more comments about scuffing and care.

• Choose the Mariska Bootie if you want a black faux-suede ankle boot that reads dressier and pairs with jeans or a skirt.
• Choose the Elegantia Goods platform loafers if you want a slip-on with a low chunky heel, a wide-width option and a choice of colors.