Masonite Cheyenne Fiberglass Entry Door vs MMI Door Fiberglass 4-Lite Front Door

The Masonite Cheyenne is the safer pick for most shoppers: a solid polyurethane core, a painted satin finish in several colors, and a 36 x 80 prehung slab that installs like a standard door. The MMI Door is the one to pick when you want daylight and a modern look, since its four-lite clear glass and Energy Star rating are things the Masonite lacks. Owners rate the Masonite around 4.1 out of 5, with complaints mostly about finish and fit; the MMI has too few ratings to judge, so treat its glass and frame as the draw and check the unit in person.

• Choose the Masonite Cheyenne if you want a solid, well-insulated front door with no glass, a painted finish you can match to trim, and a standard 36 x 80 prehung fit.
• Choose the MMI Door if you want clear glass panels to bring light into the entry and an Energy Star rated unit.