StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Max Mara Madame Trench Coat vs Mackintosh Dunkeld Trench Coat

The Max Mara Madame is the icon: an oversized, unstructured wool-cashmere coat with kimono sleeves, wide lapels and a tie belt. The Mackintosh Dunkeld is the quieter, more tailored option, single-breasted with a concealed placket and a regular fit. Owners of the Madame praise its drape and warmth but note the oversized cut swallows smaller frames and the light colors need careful dry cleaning. The Dunkeld suits someone who wants a clean, understated line and a more conventional fit.

  • Choose the Max Mara Madame if you want the recognizable oversized silhouette, kimono sleeves and belted volume that made this coat an icon.
  • Choose the Mackintosh Dunkeld if you prefer a regular-fit, single-breasted coat with a concealed placket and a cleaner, less dramatic line.

Prices

  • Max Mara Madame Trench Coat: $2,110.00 at ModeSens (last seen Nov 14)
  • Mackintosh Dunkeld Trench Coat: $1,268.00 at Editorialist (last seen Nov 14)
  • Difference: the Mackintosh Dunkeld Trench Coat is $842.00 cheaper than the Max Mara Madame Trench Coat at the latest prices (Nov 14)
Max Mara
Max Mara Madame Trench Coat

Max Mara Madame Trench Coat

$2,110.00at ModeSensChecked Nov 14
See all prices and details
Visit ModeSens
Pros
  • Iconic 101801 design with a distinctive oversized drape
  • Wool-cashmere cloth feels soft and warm
  • Tie belt lets you adjust the volume
  • Wide lapels and horn buttons read as classic luxury
  • Made in Italy
Cons
  • Oversized cut can overwhelm petite frames
  • Light colors show marks and need dry cleaning
  • Kimono sleeves limit layering under the arm
Mackintosh
Mackintosh Dunkeld Cotton Gabardine Trench Coat

Mackintosh Dunkeld Trench Coat

Mackintosh Dunkeld Cotton Gabardine Trench Coat

$1,268.00at EditorialistChecked Nov 14
See all prices and details
Visit Editorialist
Pros
  • Regular fit suits more body types
  • Concealed placket gives a clean front
  • Wool-cashmere blend at a similar fiber content
  • Classic collar works with high-neck layers
  • Made in the UK
Cons
  • No belt, so no waist definition
  • Single-breasted cut is less dramatic
  • Fewer size options listed

What separates them

Max Mara Madame Trench CoatMackintosh Dunkeld Trench Coat
SilhouetteOversized and unstructured, drapes away from the bodyRegular fit, closer to the body
ClosureDouble-breasted with contrasting horn buttonsSingle-breasted with a concealed button placket
SleevesKimono sleeves that fold up at the cuffSet-in long sleeves
Fabric90% virgin wool, 10% cashmere beaver cloth90% wool, 10% cashmere blend
BeltRemovable matching tie belt includedNo belt
Lapels and collarWide lapelsClassic collar with high neck option
OriginMade in ItalyMade in the United Kingdom
LengthKnee lengthMid-length, about 104 cm in size 40

Price history

$4,490.00$1,268.00
Nov 7Nov 21
  • Max Mara Madame Trench Coat: lowest $2,110.00 on Nov 14 at ModeSens; $4,350.00 on Nov 21.
  • Mackintosh Dunkeld Trench Coat: lowest $1,268.00 on Nov 14 at Editorialist.

Prices at every store

Max Mara Madame Trench Coat

  • ModeSensNew

    In stock

    $2,110.00Checked Nov 14
    Visit ModeSens
  • LN-CCNew

    Availability unknown

    $2,694.00Checked Nov 14
    Visit LN-CC
  • farfetch.comNew

    Availability unknownShips from abroad · duties may apply

    $3,106.00Checked Nov 14
    Visit farfetch.com
  • BlueflyNew

    Availability unknown

    $4,233.44Checked Nov 14
    Visit Bluefly
All 18 stores and price history →

Mackintosh Dunkeld Trench Coat

  • EditorialistNew

    In stock

    $1,268.00Free shippingChecked Nov 14
    Visit Editorialist
  • eBayPre-owned

    In stockSold by tatakiy0

    $1,518.80Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit eBay

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 2 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecMax Mara Madame Trench CoatMackintosh Dunkeld Trench Coat
FitOversizedRegular
SizeSize 2, Size 38, Size 40—
MaterialCashmere, Satin, Wool Blend, Wool—
Fastener TypeButton—
ColorBlack—
TypeOvercoat—
With BeltYes—
Size TypeRegular—
Double BreastedYes—
Care InstructionsDry Clean—
LengthKnee—
With LapelYes—
Show all 21 specsShow fewer specs
SpecMax Mara Madame Trench CoatMackintosh Dunkeld Trench Coat
Sleeve StyleLong Sleeve—
Made in—United Kingdom
Fabric—Wool Cashmere Blend
Composition—90% Wool 10% Cashmere
Placket—Concealed button placket
Coat style—Single-breasted
Length (size 40)—104
Chest (size 40)—60.5
Sleeve (size 40)—66.05

What reviewers say

Max Mara Madame Trench Coat

Owners of the 101801 line praise the wool-cashmere cloth, the fluid drape and the oversized cut that layers over anything. The recurring complaints are the loose volume on smaller frames and the dry-clean-only care.

What people mention
  • FabricPraisedOwners describe the virgin wool and cashmere cloth as soft, warm and substantial.
  • DrapePraisedThe unstructured cut and kimono sleeves are said to hang fluidly rather than hold a stiff shape.
  • FitMixedThe oversized cut layers well, but reviewers say it can swamp smaller frames.
  • CareCriticisedDry clean only and careful storage are the upkeep owners mention most.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a petite frame?
The Mackintosh Dunkeld. Its regular fit and set-in sleeves follow the body, while the Madame's oversized cut and kimono sleeves can swamp a smaller frame unless you size down.
Which coat is warmer?
They are close. Both use a 90% wool, 10% cashmere blend. The Madame's beaver cloth is denser and its oversized cut allows more layering, so it edges ahead in cold weather.
Is the Madame worth stepping up to over the Dunkeld?
If you want the recognizable silhouette and the tie belt, yes. If you want a restrained, tailored coat that works in more formal settings, the Dunkeld is the better match.
Which lasts longer?
Both are well-made wool coats. The Madame's unstructured construction and soft cloth can pill and lose shape with heavy wear; the Dunkeld's firmer gabardine-style weave holds its line longer.
Can I wear the Madame belted and unbelted?
Yes. The belt is removable, so you can cinch the waist or leave it open for a looser, draped look.
Does the Dunkeld work for formal occasions?
Yes. The concealed placket and classic collar give it a clean, understated line that suits business and evening wear better than the Madame's casual oversized shape.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Burberry The Long Kensington Heritage Trench Coat vs Mackintosh Dunkeld Cotton Gabardine Trench Coat
  • Burberry The Short Kensington Heritage Trench Coat vs Mackintosh Dunkeld Cotton Gabardine Trench Coat
  • Max Mara Madame Trench Coat vs Burberry The Long Kensington Heritage Trench Coat
  • Max Mara Madame Trench Coat vs Burberry The Short Kensington Heritage Trench Coat

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best trench coats and Burberry alternatives