Which gives more volume, Sky High or The Falsies Surreal?

The Falsies Surreal claims 10X volume, the bigger volume claim of the two. Sky High gives full volume but is built to stay light and not weigh lashes down.

Which is better for sensitive eyes or contact lenses?

The Falsies Surreal. It is ophthalmologist tested and lists sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers as typical users. Sky High makes no such claim.

Which lasts longer on the lashes?

The Falsies Surreal states up to 24-hour wear. Sky High is described as long-lasting but gives no hours, so expect a shorter wear window.

Is The Falsies Surreal worth the extra 19 cents?

Yes if you want the bigger 0.3 fl oz tube, 24-hour wear and sensitive-eye testing. If you want the higher-rated, lighter formula, Sky High at $10.80 is the better buy.

Does either mascara come in waterproof?

The Falsies Surreal lists waterproof among its properties. Sky High is the washable version, so it removes with water and isn't marketed as waterproof.

How do the shade ranges compare?

Sky High offers seven shades, including Blue Mist, Burgundy Haze and Space Diamond. The Falsies Surreal sticks to four black and brown shades.

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara vs Maybelline The Falsies Surreal Mascara

Both are Maybelline volume-and-length mascaras near $11, so the choice comes down to lash style and wear. The Falsies Surreal gives more dramatic volume, a larger 0.3 fl oz tube and up to 24-hour wear, while Sky High is lighter, easier to layer and rated higher by shoppers. As of November 7, 2026, Sky High is $10.80 at Walmart and The Falsies Surreal is $10.99 at Target, a 19-cent gap.

Today the Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara costs $0.19 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.