Which is better for a round toilet?

Both are round seats. The Mayfair is the safer pick because its fit and hinges are clearly specified; the Ikohbadg lists an 18.11 x 14.17 in bowl, so measure yours first.

The Mayfair, on paper. Vinyl over a wood core holds its shape better than foam cushioning, which tends to compress with use.

Is the Mayfair worth the extra money?

At $32.09 versus $21.46, yes if you sit for long stretches or want hinges that stay tight. The gap is about $11.

Why does the Ikohbadg rate only 3 out of 5?

Only 8 buyers rated it, and the average is middling. Treat it as a budget seat, not a long-term one.

Are these seats easy to install?

Both are described as simple to install. The Mayfair's secure hinges are the more durable design of the two.

Mayfair Padded Toilet Seat, Cushioned Soft Vinyl over Wood Core Seat, Secure Hinges, Easy Clean, Made in USA, Round, Bone vs Ikohbadg Padded Toilet Seat, Soft Padded Vinyl Toilet Seat, Featuring Comfort Foam Cushioning, Compatible with Standard Size Toilets, Simple Installation, Blue

Buy the Mayfair if you want a padded seat that holds up and fits a standard round bowl; its wood core and secure hinges are the reason it costs about $11 more. Buy the Ikohbadg only if the lowest price is the deciding factor and you accept a thinner foam cushion and a 3-out-of-5 rating from 8 buyers. As of November 4, 2026, the Mayfair is $32.09 at eBay and the Ikohbadg is $21.46 at Walmart.

Today the Ikohbadg Padded Toilet Seat, Soft Padded Vinyl Toilet Seat, Featuring Comfort Foam Cushioning, Compatible with Standard Size Toilets, Simple Installation, Blue costs $10.63 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent