Psycho Bunny Big & Tall Classic Crew Neck Tee vs Psycho Bunny Big & Tall Classic Piqué Polo

Both are Psycho Bunny big-and-tall tops in 100% Pima cotton, made in Peru with taped shoulder seams and the 4,000-stitch logo. The polo is the stronger product: 87 ratings at 4.9 versus 14 at 5.0, and it adds a crease-resistant collar, mother-of-pearl buttons, side vents and memory cuffs. The tee is the simpler, lighter buy. Owners of both praise the fabric and fit; the polo's main complaint is that it feels expensive, and tall shoppers wish the tee came in more variety.

• Choose the crew neck tee if you want a plain, smooth Pima cotton basic for layering or everyday wear and don't need a collar.
• Choose the piqué polo if you want one shirt that works dressed up or casual, with a collar that holds its shape and details that justify the step up.