Gobi Cashmere Men's Turtleneck vs Club Room Men's Cashmere Cable-Knit Turtleneck

The Gobi turtleneck is the stronger knit: 70% cashmere and 30% silk in a fine-gauge 1-ply, so it drapes thin and layers under a jacket, and its 5-out-of-5 ratings are consistent. The Club Room is a heavier cable-knit in 100% cashmere with a chunkier, more casual look, but it is a Macy's exclusive with thin owner feedback and at least one buyer reporting a non-delivery. Buy the Gobi for a refined, layerable turtleneck; buy the Club Room if you want a thick textured sweater and can accept less proven quality.

• Choose the Gobi Cashmere turtleneck if you want a fine-gauge silk-blend knit that layers cleanly under a blazer and has a strong, consistent rating record.
• Choose the Club Room cable-knit if you want a chunky 100% cashmere turtleneck with visible texture for casual wear.