Arctic Cool Men's Cooling Button Down vs Wrangler Men's Short Sleeve Button-Up Shirt

Buy the Arctic Cool if heat is your problem: HydroFreeze X, ActiveWick, UPF 50+ and 4-way stretch make it the better hot-weather shirt, and the click-front closure is a real help for stiff or arthritic hands. Buy the Wrangler if you want a Western-print cotton shirt with a relaxed cut, two chest pockets and a pencil slot, and you don't need cooling tech. Owners rate the Arctic Cool highly and call it cool, light and wrinkle-free; the main doubts are whether the magnetic closure feels secure and a sizing mix-up one buyer hit. The Wrangler is the more traditional shirt, but it is cotton, hand wash only, and has no sun rating or stretch claims beyond "stretch fabric."

• Choose the Arctic Cool if you run hot, work outdoors, or have hand mobility issues that make small buttons hard.
• Choose the Wrangler if you want an earthy Western print, chest pockets and a relaxed cotton fit for casual wear.